After two hours of speakers in the Public Hearing, the Brooks County Commission this Monday denied the Special Exception for Morven Solar, 3:1:1.
Speakers, Decision: Morven Solar @ Brooks County Commission 2023-02-06
Commissioner Myra Exum, after saying that whatever the Commissioners did they would be wrong, moved to approve with conditions, but got no second.
Commissioner James Maxwell moved to approve, with a second by Willie Cody. They and Chair Patrick Folsom voted to deny. Myra Exum voted no on the motion to deny. Commissioner Lee Larko abstained.
Asked by the Chair later why he had abstained, Lee Larko said it was because of what he said in the Planning Commission meeting.
Which is puzzling, because all he said in the actual Public Hearing at the Planning Commission was, “I want to say I’m against. That’s all.” I don’t understand the difficulty of voting against if that was still his position, or voting for if further evidence or testimony had persuaded him, especially after he asked many questions in the County Commission Public Hearing.
If I heard her correctly, Sherry Davidson of SGRC, acting as staff for Brooks COunty, indicated that the six additional documents received that day from Pine Gate Renewables had alleviated all her concerns. I have copies of those documents and will publish them soon, along with the rest of the board packet. I will send another open records request for the road agreement only the county attorney had seen before that meeting.
Before Commissioner James Maxwell made the motion to deny, he had asked for extra time for former county agent Johnny Whiddon. Which is curious, because Whiddon presented no evidence for any of his extraordinary claims, other than that there is an aquifer recharge zone next to the Little River east of Morven. Solar panels are acutally made mostly out of glass, aluminum, copper, and silicon, not his scare materials of lead, arsenic, silver, and cadmium. I’m more concerned about cotton pesticides and fertilizers getting into the aquifer. More on that later.
Don’t be surprised if legal action ensues.
Below are links to each WWALS video of each speaker, followed by a WWALS video playlist. These videos cover the entire meeting, except for a few seconds lost to changing camera batteries or cycling off and on between speakers.
See also:
- Report: Conditions wanted on Morven Solar by Brooks County Planning Commission 2023-01-20,
- Videos: Morven Solar at Brooks County Planning Commission 2023-01-19
- Herbivores, sediment basins, silt fences for Morven Solar –WWALS to Brooks County Commission 2023-02-06.
-jsq, John S. Quarterman, Suwannee RIVERKEEPER®
You can join this fun and work by becoming a WWALS member today!
https://wwals.net/donations/
-
Before
-
Prayer before Public Hearing for Morven Solar
-
Shuffling papers
-
Method for Public Hearing –Jason Kemp, County Attorney
-
Special Exception Decision: at end, Monthly meeting –Patrick Folsom, Chair
-
Public Hearing called to Order –Patrick Folsom, Chair
-
Six additional documents –Sherry Davidson, SGRC
-
Plus a road agreement only the County Attorney has seen
-
Pine Gate Solar presentation –Mikala Newsom
-
Pine Gate Solar presentation (cont.) –Mikala Newsom
-
Economic Development –Stephanie Williams, E.D.
-
20. minutes for, 2 minutes each speaker
-
Additional income –Irvin Lawson
-
Darrell Fraser not present
-
Mikayla Martin for
-
Robin Plymale for
-
Libby Chappell for
-
Calling Jerry Sapp
-
Farming and make a little money –Jerry Sapp, 650 Lawson Pond Road
-
Applicants’ attorney –Bill Nijem
-
Economic advantage –Cannan Lawson McLeod
-
Somebody for
-
Jess Merwin for
-
Gavin Merwin for
-
Jeri Salas(?) for
-
Somebody else for
-
Jackie McLeod for
-
Another somebody for
-
Jerry ? for
-
Chloe Sapp for
-
Chloe Sapp for
-
Facets of change, clean energy production –Barbara Lawson, 381 Hicks St.
-
Calling Becky ?
-
Calling Frances ?
-
Calling Mikala Newsom
-
Calling Macey ?
-
Somebody, Jim ?, Andrew ?, Billy Lovett for; calling Jerry Sapp Jr.
-
Freedom to do what they want with their land –Jerry Sapp Jr.
-
Anna Sapp for; calling Howard Lawson
-
Sun not coal to diversify farming –Howard Irvin Lawson
-
Why can a farmer not lease acres for solar? –Beth Lawson
-
Need solar to continue farming –One of the landowners
-
No job losses; financial boost for county –Stuart Chappell, 2500 Cooper Rd
-
Quiet solar panels to keep the farm –Freddy Dale
-
Dennis Plymale, Brandon Edmonson, Dale Rackley for
-
With safeguards, upland streambuffer –John S. Quarterman, Suw. Riverkeeper
-
Rather see orchard on Guess Road –Bill Brannen
-
Incompatible with Comprehensive Plan; photos of bald eagle –Blake McLeod
-
In front of Section 3 and 4 –Jeff Hooser, 530 Peach Road
-
Unknown
-
Property value –Unknown
-
Aquifer recharge (extra 20 seconds) –Johnny Whiddon, former county agent
-
Dead Air
-
Extra 20 seconds for –Mikala Newsom, Pine Gate Solar
-
Property appraisals –Richard C. Kirkland for Pine Gate Solar
-
Brooks did not answer appraisal survey –Wayne Waldron, Chief Appraiser
-
2. Call to Order, second prayer, pledge
-
3. Approval of Minutes
-
4. No invited guests nor 5. reports from committees or departments
-
6. A. Enterprise Fleet Management –Vehicle Replacement
-
8. A. Approve Morven Solar with conditions by Myra Exum failed, no second
-
8. A. Deny Morven Solar by James Maxwell, second Willie Cody, passes 3:1:1
-
8. B. Georgia Dept of Early Care and Learning –New Grant
-
8. A. Clarify why abstained on Morven Solar –Lee Larko
-
8. C. Equipment Purchase –Road Department
-
9. A. Daniel Rowland –Fritzke Farm Lease
-
10. No Commissioner Comments; 12. Adjourn
Here’s a WWALS video playlist:
Videos: Morven Solar denied @ Brooks County Commission 2023-02-06
Video by John S. Quarterman for WWALS Watershed Coalition (WWALS).
-jsq, John S. Quarterman, Suwannee RIVERKEEPER®
You can join this fun and work by becoming a WWALS member today!
https://wwals.net/donations/
Short Link:
Pingback: Herbivores, sediment basins, silt fences for Morven Solar –WWALS to Brooks County Commission 2023-02-06 | WWALS Watershed Coalition (WWALS) is Suwannee RIVERKEEPER®
Pingback: Videos: Morven Solar at Brooks County Planning Commission 2023-01-19 | WWALS Watershed Coalition (WWALS) is Suwannee RIVERKEEPER®